🍩 Phish Setlist Tracker

← 1991-05-16 · THE STING 1991-05-18 · THE MARQUEE →

1991-05-17

CAMPUS CLUB · Providence, RI · Winter/Spring Tour 1991 Era 1.0

Set 1: Chalk Dust Torture [4:04] notes ↗, Drums -> Mr. P.C., Reba [10:54], Poor Heart [2:58] > The Oh Kee Pa Ceremony [1:41] > Suzy Greenberg [5:18], The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday > Avenu Malkenu > The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday, Stash [8:02], I Didn't Know [3:01], Mike's Song [5:57] > I Am Hydrogen [2:34] > Weekapaug Groove [6:52], Take the 'A' Train [5:53]
Set 1 total: 57:14 11 of 16 timed

Set 2: Possum [8:43] > Guelah Papyrus [5:45], Rocky Top [2:45], The Landlady [3:38] > Fluffhead -> Happy Birthday to You, Magilla [5:10] notes ↗, Cavern [4:37], Harry Hood [10:57], Hold Your Head Up > Bike > Hold Your Head Up > Big Black Furry Creature from Mars, Happy Birthday to You > Big Black Furry Creature from Mars
Set 2 total: 41:35 7 of 15 timed

Encore: Lawn Boy [2:38], Golgi Apparatus [5:00]
Encore total: 7:38

Timed portion: 1:46:27 across 20 of 33 songs — a floor, not the show's length.

Times come from phish.in and are shown only where one track maps to exactly one song. Segued songs are often released as a single bundled track carrying one duration for several songs, and a song played twice in a set can't be told apart — those get no time rather than a made-up one. 13 of 33 songs here are untimed for that reason (or because the show isn't on phish.in at all).

Notes

A blackout occurred during Chalk Dust. The drum solo and the ensuing Mr. P.C. featured Carl Gerhard on trumpet, who also performed on ‘A’ Train, Magilla, Cavern, and Lawn Boy. Mr. P.C. was performed for the first time since November 11, 1988 (338 shows) and included a Spider-Man theme tease from Gerhard. The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday was introduced as “The Old Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday.” This show fell on Page’s 28th birthday, a point noted repeatedly throughout the gig. I Didn't Know featured Fish on trombone. Fluffhead was unfinished; the rest of the band sung Happy Birthday to Page first over the Fluffhead melody, followed by the Happy Birthday melody. Happy Birthday was performed for the first time since September 29, 1990 (105 shows). Possum contained Yield Not To Temptation and I Know a Little teases. Magilla contained a full-band Flintstones theme tease. Mississippi Queen was teased during Fish's vacuum solo in Bike. The pause in BBFCFM featured a final rendition of Happy Birthday and the presentation of a cake; Fish then responded to the “how old are you?” crowd chants by counting off BBFCFM: “I’ll tell you how old he is: 1-2-3-4!”

Gap chart

How long each of tonight's songs had been on the shelf, across all Phish shows. The gap is always as of this date.

SongTimes playedLast played (overall) Last played before this showGap
Chalk Dust Torture 530 2026-09-05 1991-05-16 0
Drums 11 2009-08-02 1991-05-02 7
Mr. P.C. 3 1991-05-17 1988-11-11 276
Reba 420 2026-07-22 1991-05-11 2
Poor Heart 312 2024-12-28 1991-05-12 1
The Oh Kee Pa Ceremony 220 2024-08-02 1991-05-12 1
Suzy Greenberg 458 2026-07-24 1991-05-11 2
The Man Who Stepped Into Yesterday 88 2026-07-27 1991-05-03 6
Avenu Malkenu 86 2026-07-27 1991-05-03 6
Stash 464 2026-08-01 1991-05-12 1
I Didn't Know 267 2026-07-29 1991-05-02 7
Mike's Song 550 2026-08-01 1991-05-12 1
I Am Hydrogen 356 2026-07-22 1991-05-12 1
Weekapaug Groove 523 2026-08-01 1991-05-12 1
Take the 'A' Train 122 1994-04-13 1991-05-10 3
Possum 586 2026-09-05 1991-05-10 3
Guelah Papyrus 211 2026-07-24 1991-05-11 2
Rocky Top 208 2026-07-10 1991-05-12 1
The Landlady 216 2025-04-27 1991-05-16 0
Fluffhead 293 2026-07-24 1991-05-09 4
Happy Birthday to You 22 2023-07-23 1990-09-29 100
Magilla 72 2003-07-22 1991-05-16 0
Cavern 485 2026-07-25 1991-05-16 0
Harry Hood 445 2026-09-04 1991-05-10 3
Hold Your Head Up 314 2026-07-29 1991-05-10 3
Bike 42 2018-11-02 1990-11-10 71
Big Black Furry Creature from Mars 135 2026-07-22 1991-05-11 2
Lawn Boy 222 2025-07-25 1991-04-22 11
Golgi Apparatus 486 2026-07-24 1991-05-16 0

gold = bustout (long gap) · red = jam chart · [m:ss] = phish.in duration (click it to listen) · hover a song for its gap.

Jam-chart marks are curated by hand and lag the shows — the most recent months are sparsely marked because nobody has written them up yet, not because the jams were weak. See coverage →